Language:
English
Year of publication:
2023
Titel der Quelle:
European Judaism
Angaben zur Quelle:
56,2 (2023) 47-62
Keywords:
Gómez Silveira, Abraham,
;
New Testament Criticism, interpretation, etc., Jewish
;
Qurʼan Criticism, interpretation, etc., Jewish
;
Judaism Relations 17th century
;
Christianity
;
Judaism Relations 17th century
;
Islam
;
Apologetics History 17th century
Abstract:
Interfaith controversies and disputes regarding the role of reason in interpreting the Scriptures characterised scholarly discussion in the Low Countries between the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries. The Jewish author Abraham Gómez Silveira contributed to this discussion with an eclectic body of literature. This article focuses on his Libro Mudo (Mute Book), which embodies his efforts to present the Jewish religion as the only rational one and the Christian dogma as irrational. In order to corroborate his reading, Silveira mostly bases his argumentation on non-Jewish texts. By selecting passages from the New Testaments, Christian religious commentaries as well as Qur'anic excerpts, Silveira aims to demonstrate that even non-Jewish sources prove the rationality of the Jewish theological system. The novelty of Silveira's approach consists in confuting Christian dogma by accepting the Gospels as reliable historical sources. In this argumentative structure, the Qur'an has a similar although not identical function.
DOI:
10.3167/ej.2023.560206
URL:
Locate this publication in Israeli libraries
